Buy as little as one piece of candy to a whole box for the family to enjoy! Our specialty is old fashioned penny candy; some that dates back to the late 1800’s and early 1900’s and a huge selection of …

Mary Jane candy is a chewy taffy made with peanut butter and molasses. It's a nostalgic treat that's been popular in New England for generations. Atkinson Candy Company in Lufkin, Texas …

The family-owned confectionery produces the candy at its factory in Lufkin, Texas, where it has been making toasted coconut and fresh roasted peanut butter since the 1940s.

Get in touch 781-784-1600 10 Merchant Street Sharon, MA 02067 © 2026, The Penny Candy Store Web design by Penny Candy

Get in touch 781-784-1600 10 Merchant Street Sharon, MA 02067 © 2026, The Penny Candy Store Web design by Penny Candy

Get in touch 781-784-1600 10 Merchant Street Sharon, MA 02067 © 2026, The Penny Candy Store Web design by Penny Candy

The Penny Candy Store is a rare and massive candy shop where you can buy a single piece of penny candy or a box of old fashioned penny candy for the whole family.

Get in touch 781-784-1600 10 Merchant Street Sharon, MA 02067 © 2026, The Penny Candy Store Web design by Penny Candy

The Million Dollar Candy Bar is a sweet treat that is sure to impress. Made by Bartons Candy, this milk chocolate bar is packed with delicious flavor

If you own a retail store and would like to carry The Penny Candy Store products, please fill out the form to be approved for a wholesale account. For any questions, please email [email protected].